For the past few decades as a writer, I’ve kept long-running lists of story ideas in my Notes app, organized by topic. The longest one is called “COLUMN,” because I wrote a weekly column for The Wall Street Journal for five years and you need a lot of grist for the mill. On slow news weeks, I would scroll through my list of hundreds of half-baked thoughts (“CEO face lift time off”... “William and Kate Christmas card”... “grey sweatpants”) to see if any of them were workable. Most were not.
Since I started The Hamptons Chronicle this summer, I’ve kept a new list, and near the top of it was the unsolved case of “Montauk Mary.” The unidentified body of a woman in her 60s was found on Montauk Highway in 1978. She had been shot four times and was wearing a floral housecoat and fuzzy slippers. In a press conference last week, the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office revealed that with new DNA tracing they had identified Montauk Mary as Sofia Margherita Marrone of Pleasantville, New Jersey. The police also named the likely killer as Richard Biegenwald, a serial killer known as the “Thrill Killer,” linked to nine murders, mostly near the Jersey Shore.
How did the “Thrill Killer” end up in Montauk, more than 150 miles from his usual hunting grounds of the Jersey Shore? Biegenwald died in prison in 2008, so we’ll likely never know, but the case does dredge up the somewhat conspiratorial notion of the East End of Long Island as a kind of spooky last resort for folks on the edge. The Substacker Lauren Balik’s death at Camp Hero earlier this year also remains unexplained.
In today’s newsletter, a sneak peek at the cover of The Hamptons Chronicle’s holiday issue, with never-before-seen photos of Kate Spade at her first home in Southampton, photographed by Tierney Gearon. Plus: what happens when you try to smoke cigs in East Hampton Village; and a rare Art Village Southampton home with pedigree hits the market. Pick up your copy of THC’s holiday print issue this weekend at spots including Sagaponack General Store and Marie Eiffel.
Today’s newsletter and this week’s holiday issue are brought to you by Urban Jürgensen, a heritage watch company started in Copenhagen in 1773 and now based between New York and Switzerland. When I met the brand’s CEO, Alex Rosenfield, in Sag Harbor this summer, he was wearing the black plaid Phoebe Philo pants that matched my favorite shirt. I knew then that he had exquisite taste and we had much to discuss. Over coffee in Sag, we realized that we had far more than Phoebe in common, including a love of photography and a shared annoyance at the word “whimsy.” I’m honored to feature Urban Jürgensen as The Hamptons Chronicle’s first partner.

Kate Takes a Village
“I never saw Katy go swimming,” remembers Pamela Bell, a co-founder of Kate Spade. “She was very particular about her hair.” Kate Spade—the woman, not the brand—was known for her picture-perfect chignon. It was part of the late designer’s off-kilter mid-century look: little minks, Prada skirts, cardigans, vintage jewelry.
Kate may not have been a stereotypical beach person, but she had a long history in the Hamptons. She met Pamela in 1993 when they shared an Amagansett rental. Later, she and Andy Spade bought the Southampton Victorian shown in these photos, their first house in the WASP-y village. Their second Southampton home, a lofty open bungalow in the Shinnecock Hills “Art Village,” became a widely photographed interior design reference. But their first little Victorian was more personal.
In 2002, the Los Angeles photographer Tierney Gearon, who had shot an eerily idyllic campaign for Kate and Andy’s brand the year before, was assigned by Harper’s Bazaar to shoot the couple at home. These photos, which did not run in the magazine, show the aesthetic of Kate Spade 1.0—a world that draws from East Coast preppiness without being too literal. “Tierney Gearon was perfect for Kate Spade,” says Cary Leitzes, the photography director at the magazine at that time, who produced the shoot which she described as “a Mad Hatter tea party.” She says Tierney instinctively understood Kate’s world: “playful, colorful, idiosyncratic, a little eccentric, and totally original.”
The cover photo was shot under a tree that Pamela says they called “the weeping beech.” “It was like a room, and we’d have dinner under there sometimes,” she remembers. Pamela had lent Kate and Andy the garden furniture, and they painted it white and had striped cushions made, inspired by a Slim Aarons photo. Pamela, who had never seen these photos, was stunned to see Kate wearing purple, a famously divisive color in the studio. “But this is a good purple,” she says.
Although Kate was “so not a nature girl,” says Pamela, their time out east was full of dinner parties and laughter. “It was really more about just friendship,” she says.

A Butt Bandit
Did you know that it is against the law to smoke on the streets of East Hampton Village? In 2018, the tony village banned smoking and vaping on all public property, including sidewalks. It’s the most restrictive village on the East End, many of which prohibit smoking on beaches and close to buildings but not everywhere. As a non-smoker (since 2010, shout-out to Allen Carr) I was not aware of this law. Neither was a Flushing Uber driver who was ticketed by village police this past weekend for both smoking and littering his butt.

Own a Piece of Art History
One of Southampton’s historic gems, 9 Briar Lane in the “Art Village,” has hit the market for $6.25 million, listed by Pat Garrity and Mary Slattery at Corcoran. The house was designed by Stanford White of McKim, Mead & White, who also worked on Montauk’s “Seven Sisters” houses (another fascination of mine). Once owned by art collector Beth Rudin DeWoody, the Briar Lane house is part of a small cluster of houses that belonged to William Merritt Chase’s Shinnecock Hills Summer School of Art, which operated from 1891 to 1902.
According to an incredible 2012 report by Sally Spanburgh, the Art Village began as the site of one of America’s first art schools devoted to plein-air painting. The Briar Lane house was built for Dr. Edward L. Keyes, whose wife “didn’t like the Bohemian life of the rowdy people who lived up and down Ochre Lane and near the [Art] Studio and so she built a high privet hedge separating her property of four or five acres...from the rest of the Art Village. And they didn’t mix.”
Another famous resident of the Art Village? Our cover girl, Kate Spade, whose second home in Southampton was part of the historic group.
Wow. You reached the bottom. Reward yourself with a THC subscription, because most of our newsletters are not free like this one!








what a wonderful holiday cover. such a graceful image of Kate.
These photos gave me tears, beautiful captures